eld.gg MLB The Show 25 Stubs: Real Stub Savings Example
Buy Specific Players Instead of MLB The Show 25 Stubs Packs in MLB The Show 25
In MLB The Show 25, stubs are your most important resource, and how you choose to spend them directly affects the quality of your team and your ability to compete in Diamond Dynasty. One of the biggest and most common mistakes players make—especially early on—is spending stubs on packs in hopes of pulling a top-tier card. While ripping packs can be exciting and occasionally rewarding, it is almost always more efficient and cost-effective to buy specific players directly from the Marketplace instead.
In this guide, we’ll break down exactly why buying specific players is better than relying on packs, and how to approach building your team strategically through the in-game Marketplace.
Why Packs Are a Risky Investment
Packs may seem tempting because of the chance to pull high-value Diamond players, but the odds are heavily stacked against you. Standard packs cost 1,500 stubs and offer very low pull rates for anything higher than a Gold-tier card. For example:
Standard Pack Odds (per pack):
Diamond player: ~1 in 50 (2% chance or lower)
Gold player: ~1 in 10 (10% chance)
Silver or lower: Over 80% chance
That means that unless you're exceptionally lucky, you’re likely to spend 7,500 stubs on a 5-pack bundle and walk away with cards worth far less than what you paid.
Buying packs is essentially gambling. You may occasionally pull something valuable, but over time, you'll almost always lose stubs in the long run.
The Marketplace: A Smarter, More Predictable Option
The in-game Marketplace lets players buy and sell cards for stubs. It includes:
Live Series MLB players
Legends and Flashbacks
Equipment and Perks
Stadiums, uniforms, and more
When you know exactly what you need—whether it’s a left-handed power bat, a shutdown closer, or a card required for a collection—you can skip the guesswork and spend your stubs efficiently.
Benefits of Buying Specific Players:
Certainty: You get the exact card you want.
Better value: Avoid wasting stubs on unwanted commons and bronzes.
Build faster: You can quickly complete collections or strengthen weak spots in your lineup.
Control your team’s direction: You decide who fits your playstyle, not the RNG.
Real Stub Savings Example
Let’s say you’re looking for a solid Diamond hitter like 88 OVR Corey Seager. His market value is around 12,000–15,000 stubs. You could:
Buy 10 standard packs for 15,000 stubs, hoping to get a Diamond (and likely end up with buy MLB The Show 25 Stubs several bronzes and silvers)
Buy Seager directly, guaranteeing yourself a strong left-handed bat that will immediately impact your lineup.
The difference is clear: one option is a gamble, the other is a guaranteed upgrade.